Exploring The Lord of the Rings: A Comprehensive Review

The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings, a timeless classic often considered the reviewer’s all-time favorite book, has captivated readers and viewers alike ¹. Peter Jackson’s live-action film trilogy, released between 2001 and 2003, has garnered immense praise and admiration from fans worldwide ⁴.

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001) has received an astounding 5,805 user reviews, with many viewers regarding it as a masterpiece and awarding it perfect 10/10 ratings ². The film is lauded for its breathtaking visuals, thrilling adventure, and faithful connection to the book, with some even describing the trilogy as the best cinematographic work ever produced by mankind ². The Lord of the Rings trilogy transcends the genre of overwrought special-effects action pictures, offering a long series of episodes that pay great attention to mealtimes, landscapes, and characters, embodying a sense of innocence ³. This article delves into the creation, themes, characters, setting, impact, adaptations, and legacy of J.R.R. Tolkien’s magnum opus, exploring why The Lord of the Rings continues to captivate audiences decades after its publication ⁴ ⁵ ⁶.

The Creation of a Masterpiece

J.R.R. Tolkien’s dedication to his craft is evident in the time he took to complete “The Lord of the Rings” – between 12 to 15 years ¹. This epic tale is set in the richly detailed world of Middle-earth, which Tolkien began creating in his study ⁵. His most notable works, “The Hobbit” and “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy, are all set within this meticulously crafted universe ⁵.

Central to the story is the One Ring, a powerful artifact created by the Dark Lord Sauron to dominate Middle-earth ⁴. The One Ring was forged secretly by Sauron in Mount Doom, granting him the power to control the wearers of the other Rings of Power ⁷ ⁸ ⁹ ¹¹. These rings were created by the Elves of Eregion, with knowledge obtained from Sauron, who posed as Annatar, the Lord of Gifts ⁷ ⁸. In total, there were 20 Great Rings: 16 given to Dwarf-kings, 3 kept by the Elves, and the One Ring forged by Sauron ⁷.

The Rings of Power were the masterwork of the Gwaith-i-Mírdain of Eregion, headed by Celebrimbor ⁹. Their purpose was to preserve the beauty and power of the various races of Middle-earth ⁸. However, Sauron’s true intention was to use the rings to seduce the rulers of Middle-earth to evil and bring them under his sway ⁹ ¹⁰. Tolkien’s works, including “The Hobbit,” the first two volumes of “The Lord of the Rings,” and his translations of “Sir Gawain and the Green Knight” and “Sir Orfeo,” showcase his immense talent as a writer and his dedication to creating a rich, immersive fantasy world ⁶.

The Core Themes

The Lord of the Rings is a timeless classic that explores a range of complex themes and motifs:

Good vs. Evil:
- The story is anchored in a stable moral universe derivative of a Christian worldview, with themes like good vs. evil, friendship and loyalty, sacrifice, and power and corruption ¹⁰.
- The struggle between good and evil is a central theme ¹⁶.
- The tale explores the sharp polarity between good and evil, but also suggests that no definite line can be drawn between the two ¹⁴.
Power and Corruption:
- The plot deals with complex issues, such as the nature of absolute power and its potential to corrupt ¹.
- The corrupting influence of the One Ring through the power it offers is a major theme ¹⁴ ¹⁶ ¹⁸.
- The One Ring symbolizes sin and is a metaphor for the devil’s third temptation of Christ ¹⁵.
Friendship and Loyalty:
- Friendship is a significant theme, as depicted through the formation of the Fellowship ¹⁵.
- The importance of friendship and loyalty is explored ¹⁶.
Death and Immortality:
- The core theme of the story is death and the human desire to escape it ¹⁴ ¹⁵.
- The story explores the concept of death and immortality, with the Rings of Power promising immortality to Men but eventually sucking away their lives ¹⁵.
Fate and Free Will:
- The story combines fate and free will, with past decisions having a critical influence on current events ¹⁴ ¹⁵.
- Fate plays a significant role in the story, with events and decisions influencing other events ¹⁵.
Environmentalism and Criticism of Technology:
- The series has a strong focus on industrialization vs. the natural world, with Sauron and his servants creating war camps, destroying forests and lands, and creating factories for weapons in lands that used to be sacred and natural ¹¹.
- Environmentalism and criticism of technology are evident in the depiction of Saruman’s industrial hell and the impact of industrial technology on the Shire ¹⁴.
Religious and Mythical Themes:
- The Lord of the Rings carries Christian themes and motifs, such as the presence of Christ figures, the resurrection, hope, and redemptive suffering ¹⁴ ¹⁵.
- The story is not an allegory but carries religious implications, with themes such as pity and mercy, hope and obedience, faith in beauty, providence, kenotic sacrifice, the powers and intercession, temptation, the common life, sacramentalism, eschatological longing, eucatastrophe, and mythic participation ¹⁷.
- The power of myth is a theme, with stories and lore defining characters in Middle-earth ¹⁸.

The Lord of the Rings is primarily a milieu story, focusing on exploring the world of Middle Earth ¹⁹. The narrative starts when a character sets off to explore new places and ends when this exploration is complete ¹⁹. However, it is not a pure milieu story as Tolkien wants to explore the Shire itself at the beginning and the story does not end until we see the Shire again and find out the eventual fate of Middle Earth ¹⁹.

Main Characters and Their Journeys

The Lord of the Rings features a diverse cast of characters, each with their own unique journeys and roles in the story. The main characters include:

Frodo Baggins: A hobbit who inherits the One Ring from his uncle Bilbo and becomes the Ringbearer, tasked with destroying it in the fires of Mount Doom. Frodo’s journey is one of sacrifice and perseverance, as he struggles with the burden of the Ring and the hardships of the quest ²¹ ²³.
Samwise Gamgee: Frodo’s loyal friend and companion, who proves to be brave, strong, and essential to the success of the mission. Sam’s unwavering dedication to Frodo and their friendship is a central theme in the story ²⁰ ²³.
Gandalf: A powerful wizard who guides and protects the Fellowship, Gandalf is a mentor figure to many of the characters. He undergoes a transformation from Gandalf the Grey to Gandalf the White, becoming more powerful but less relatable ²¹ ²³.
Aragorn: A Ranger of the North who is revealed to be the rightful heir to the throne of Gondor. Aragorn’s journey is one of accepting his destiny and becoming a wise and caring leader ²² ²³ ²⁴.
Legolas and Gimli: An elf and a dwarf who form an unlikely friendship despite the historical animosity between their races. While Legolas remains largely unchanged, Gimli grows to accept and respect elves ²¹ ²³.
Merry and Pippin: Two young hobbits who are initially naive and immature but are forced to grow up quickly due to their experiences on the journey ²¹ ²³.

Other notable characters include Boromir, a proud warrior of Gondor who struggles with the temptation of the Ring ²⁰ ²¹; Éowyn, a shieldmaiden of Rohan who becomes a fierce warrior and slays the Witch-king ²³; and Bilbo Baggins, Frodo’s uncle who found the Ring and passed it on to him ²³.

The Rings of Power play a significant role in shaping the characters and their journeys:

The Nine Rings given to men turned them into the Nazgûl, enslaved by Sauron ⁷ ⁸.
The Seven Rings given to the Dwarves allowed them to establish treasure hoards, but due to their natural hardiness, Sauron could not control them as easily ⁷.
The Three Rings of the Elves, forged by Celebrimbor and untouched by Sauron, granted their wearers the power to heal and preserve ⁷.

Throughout the story, the characters face numerous challenges and undergo significant changes, with their qualities of love, loyalty, justice, and mercy enabling them to persevere and ultimately triumph over the forces of darkness ¹⁰.

Middle-earth: Setting and Significance

Middle-earth, the central continent of Arda in J.R.R. Tolkien’s imagined mythological past, serves as the rich and immersive setting for his fantasy works, including The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings ¹² ¹³. This meticulously crafted world is inhabited by various humanoid races, such as Men, Elves, Dwarves, Hobbits, Ents, and Dragons ¹² ²⁵, each with their own unique cultures, languages, and histories ⁵ ¹¹.

The geography of Middle-earth is reminiscent of old Europe in the Middle Ages and earlier ²⁴, with locations mirroring countries in our own world ²⁴ ²⁶. The continent is divided into several regions, including:

The Westlands
Harad
Rhûn
Cuiviénen
Hildorien ²⁵

Notable geographical features include:

The Blue Mountains
The Misty Mountains
The Red Mountains
The Yellow Mountains
The Mountains of the Wind ²⁵

The story’s structure in The Lord of the Rings focuses on Frodo’s Hobbit companions before delivering a split narrative, with nearly equal time spent between the events leading up to and consisting of the War of the Ring and Frodo and Sam’s perilous journey into the depths of Mordor ¹. The Shire, home to the Hobbits, serves as a fantasy of home for Frodo and Sam, representing a peaceful, idyllic life free from war and hardship ²⁷.

Throughout the history of Middle-earth, the Rings of Power played a significant role, with 9 rings given to men, 7 to dwarves, and 3 to elves ⁸. The 3 Elven Rings, Nenya, Narya, and Vilya, were given to Gil-Galad, Círdan, and Galadriel respectively ⁸. The Valar, powerful angelic beings, initially played a significant role in the affairs of Middle-earth but later withdrew, leaving the struggle against evil to the other races ¹². Ultimately, Middle-earth is saved from Sauron by grace, with divine intervention playing a crucial role ¹⁰.

Tolkien’s approach to world-building and depth of lore, including the creation of unique languages like Elvish, has influenced many contemporary fantasy writers ⁵. Middle-earth serves not only as a backdrop for his invented languages but also as a vehicle for Tolkien to explore their evolution and usage within a fictional context ¹³, as well as to create his own rich mythological and legendary traditions ¹³.

The Impact on Pop Culture

The Lord of the Rings has had an enormous influence on the high fantasy genre and has been adapted into a successful film trilogy, winning a total of 17 Oscars ²⁸ ³⁰. The adventure aspect of the series initially attracts people, but themes of friendship and loyalty keep them coming back, as the story resonates with many, featuring not just great swordsmen and archers but small creatures doing their best ³⁰. The books have influenced the fantasy genre, providing room for various interests and research opportunities, while the movies have significantly impacted the film industry ³⁰.

The Lord of the Rings has also inspired numerous other forms of media, including:

Computer and video games, such as The Lord of the Rings: Gollum, Middle-earth: Shadow of War, and The Lord of the Rings Online ²⁹ ³²
Role-playing games, like Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) and Middle-Earth Role-Playing (MERP) ³¹
Music, with various artists and bands drawing inspiration from the series, including The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, and Enya ³²
Television, radio, and literature, with references and parodies appearing in shows like Friends, South Park, and The Simpsons, as well as books by authors such as J.K. Rowling and Terry Pratchett ³²

The impact of The Lord of the Rings extends beyond the fantasy genre, influencing game-worlds based on Medieval, Renaissance, or other Sword & Sorcery settings ³¹. The series has also been compared to legendary stories like those of King Arthur and Robin Hood, which influenced Tolkien’s writings ³¹. With the recent release of the Rings of Power series and fans’ continued passion for the franchise, as evidenced by their attendance at events like Fan Expo in Toronto, The Lord of the Rings remains a significant piece of pop culture ³⁰.

Adaptations and Interpretations

The Lord of the Rings has been adapted into various forms of media, including:

Films:
- The Lord of the Rings (1978) by Ralph Bakshi ²⁹
- The Return of the King (1980) by Rankin-Bass ²⁹
- The Hobbit (1985) – Live-action TV special produced in the Soviet Union ²⁹
- Khraniteli (1991) – Pilot for an animated Hobbit series ²⁹
- The Fellowship of the Ring (2022) – Live-action television play, newly discovered and uploaded in Russia’s Channel 5 YouTube Channel in 2 parts ²⁹
Television:
- Sagan om ringen (1971) – Swedish live action television film ²⁹
- Hobitit (1993) – Finnish live action television miniseries ²⁹
Radio:
- BBC broadcast in 1955 and 1956 ²⁹
- BBC Radio 4 production in 1981 ²⁹
- WBAI-FM broadcast in 1972 ²⁹
- National Public Radio broadcast in 1979 ²⁹
- German radio stations Südwestrundfunk and Westdeutscher Rundfunk broadcast in 1992 ²⁹
- Danish radio station Danmarks Radio broadcast in 1999-2000 ²⁹
- Slovak radio series in 1999-2003 ²⁹
Stage:
- The Lord of the Rings comedy musical in Cincinnati, Ohio ²⁹
- Lifeline Theatre in Chicago, Illinois ²⁹
- Large-scale three-and-a-half-hour musical in Toronto (2006) ²⁹
- Musical parody of The Fellowship of the Ring, Fellowship! (2005) ²⁹
Audiobooks:
- The Library of Congress recorded unabridged versions in 1967, 1978, and 1999 ²⁹
- Rob Inglis read and performed an unabridged version for Recorded Books in 1990 ²⁹
- Andy Serkis recorded an unabridged version for HarperCollins and Recorded Books in 2021 ²⁹

Christopher Tolkien, J.R.R. Tolkien’s son, published several works based on his father’s extensive notes and unpublished manuscripts, including ‘The Silmarillion’ ³⁶. These posthumous publications have expanded the lore and mythology of Middle-earth.

The Fellowship of the Ring, a group of nine heroes in The Lord of the Rings, was formed by Elrond to carry the One Ring to Mordor and destroy it ³⁷. The Fellowship consists of representatives from different races in Middle-earth: Gandalf, Legolas, Gimli, Aragorn, Boromir, Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin ³⁷. Gandalf, being a Maia and an Istar, is considered the strongest member of the Fellowship ³⁷. During their journey, two members of the Fellowship die: Boromir and Gandalf, although Gandalf is later resurrected as Gandalf the White ³⁷.

Comparative Analysis with Other Fantasy Works

Tolkien’s works have shaped the modern fantasy genre, introducing many of the elements that have come to define high fantasy, such as epic quests, powerful magical artifacts, and ancient prophecies ³³. The Lord of the Rings (LOTR) is often considered a classic of the fantasy genre due to its rich world-building, complex characters, and epic storytelling ³⁸. Tolkien’s work is the first high fantasy fiction done well, influencing the genre significantly and setting a precedent for subsequent works ³⁸.

Some popular fantasy series that readers who enjoy LOTR might also appreciate include:

The Bitterbynde Trilogy, The Ill-Made Mute by Cecilia Dart-Thornton: A mute, with no memories, sets out to find a past, a name, and a destiny ³⁹. The book is deeply rooted in ancient British folklore ³⁹ and has been praised as a ‘beautifully spun fantasy’ and compared to The Lord of the Rings by Andre Norton ³⁹.
The Chronicles of Narnia By C.S. Lewis: This series is a great chaser to accompany or a predecessor for younger readers ⁴⁰. It draws from the classics, incorporating fauns, mermaids, and minotaurs along with elves and wizards ⁴⁰.
The Earthsea Cycle by Ursula K. LeGuin: This series has a bit more oomph in its use of magic and coming-of-age structure ⁴⁰. It is impeccably mystical and draws from C.S. Lewis as well as Tolkien ⁴⁰.
The Wheel Of Time Series By Robert Jordan: This series has an immense realm of magic and majesty with wizards, warriors, and heavy themes evoked from the War of the Ring ⁴⁰. It is not a quick read, but it definitely has Middle-Earth matched in epic scale ⁴⁰. The story follows three peasant boys who must stop the Dark One from plunging the world into chaos ³⁹. The epic high fantasy saga is so compelling and beloved that when Jordan died, Brandon Sanderson stepped up to finish the series ³⁹.

Other notable fantasy works that have been compared to or inspired by The Lord of the Rings include:

The Dragonlance Chronicles By Wise and Hickman ⁴⁰
The Stand By Stephen King ⁴⁰
The Chronicles Of Prydain By Lloyd Alexander ⁴⁰
The Shannara Series By Terry Brooks ⁴⁰
The Legend of Drizzt by R. A. Salvatore ³⁹

The comparison of LOTR to other fantasy books is often done to generate interest in other works or as part of review or scholarly inquiry ³⁸. These comparisons highlight the enduring influence and impact of Tolkien’s masterpiece on the fantasy genre.

The Legacy of J.R.R. Tolkien

J.R.R. Tolkien’s legacy is one of unparalleled depth, detail, and imagination in the realm of fantasy literature. His masterpiece, The Lord of the Rings, has captivated readers for generations, selling over 150 million copies since its first publication in 1937, with an average of approximately 2.5 million books sold each year ⁴². The sheer size, depth, and detail of the novel are admired by many, with Tolkien’s magic and talent considered unmatched by many writers ¹. The novel’s strength lies in its detailed world-building and mythic quality, making it a testament to Tolkien’s ability to blend his academic interests in language and mythology with storytelling ⁴¹.

Tolkien’s life experiences played a significant role in shaping his literary works. His childhood in Sarehole, England, served as an inspiration for the Shire in his Middle-Earth sagas ⁵. Tolkien’s love for languages began in his early years, influenced by his mother who taught him Latin, French, and German ⁵. His academic pursuits led him to Exeter College, Oxford, where he studied Classics before transitioning to English Language and Literature ⁵ ⁶. Tolkien’s service in the Lancashire Fusiliers during World War I had a profound impact on his perspectives and writing ⁵ ⁶. Despite personal and financial challenges, Tolkien made significant contributions to the academic world, including his research paper ‘Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics’, which significantly influenced the perception of ‘Beowulf’ in literary circles ⁵.

Tolkien’s impact on the literary world is significant, with ‘The Lord of the Rings’ and ‘The Hobbit’ reshaping the landscape of fantasy literature ⁵. The trilogy, based on Tolkien’s classic high fantasy novel series ¹¹, is highly recommended for those seeking a relatively short series that’s easy to read, transports the reader to a different world, and keeps the reader on the edge of their seat ¹¹. The series contains redemptive metaphors, Christian virtues, and veiled references to divine providence and Christ-analogies ¹⁰, anchored in a stable moral universe derivative of a Christian worldview ¹⁰. The literary quality of Tolkien’s poetry and prose is outstanding, and his message and presuppositions are profound ¹⁰, with the moral in his work derivative of Christian insights into reality ¹⁰. J.R.R. Tolkien is widely regarded as one of the most influential authors of all time, with his writing having a significant impact on the fantasy genre ³⁶.

Conclusion

The Lord of the Rings, J.R.R. Tolkien’s magnum opus, has left an indelible mark on the literary world and popular culture. Through its rich world-building, complex characters, and exploration of profound themes, the novel has captivated readers for generations. Tolkien’s masterpiece has not only reshaped the landscape of fantasy literature but has also inspired countless adaptations and interpretations across various media.

Tolkien’s legacy extends far beyond the pages of his novels, as his works continue to inspire and influence writers, filmmakers, and artists around the world. The enduring success of The Lord of the Rings serves as a testament to Tolkien’s unparalleled imagination, storytelling prowess, and the timeless nature of his themes. As readers continue to discover and rediscover the magic of Middle-earth, Tolkien’s legacy will undoubtedly live on, solidifying his place as one of the most influential authors of all time.

FAQs

Is “The Lord of the Rings” considered a challenging book to read?

While “The Lord of the Rings” is a beloved classic, some readers may find it daunting, particularly if they are not familiar with fantasy literature or older styles of prose. The novel’s extensive world-building, complex storyline, and multitude of characters can be quite overwhelming for newcomers.

What makes “The Lord of the Rings” books so compelling?

“The Lord of the Rings” is celebrated for its profound narrative that explores transformation, redemption, suffering, and victory. These elements weave together to create a deeply human story that resonates with readers, culminating in a powerful exploration of the story’s themes in the final act.

How much time does it usually take to read “The Lord of the Rings”?

On average, it takes about 37 hours and 36 minutes to read “The Lord of the Rings” for someone reading at a speed of 250 words per minute. Your personal reading time may vary, and you can determine your reading speed by taking a words-per-minute test.

What are the reasons behind the enduring popularity of “The Lord of the Rings”?

The epic conflict between Frodo, the Fellowship, and Sauron offers a fantastical parallel to real-world challenges without being too close to reality, allowing readers and viewers an immersive escape. This ability to provide a respite from personal troubles is a key factor in the story’s lasting appeal.

References